We have stayed at this property many times, but this time it seemed that the quality of the experience was greatly diminished. There was nothing hugely wrong - the property is clean, close to SBU, quiet and felt safe. However, it was the myriad of little things that made it a lesser experience than it has been in the past.
The beds were ok, but the bedding was very annoying. Our comforters were tucked in so tightly - and about waist-high when we lay down - that we couldn't get comfortable at night without totally stripping the bed and remaking it. None of the outlets seemed to work. The lotion bottle in the bathroom was obviously used and empty, which felt kind of yucky. The grout in the shower was obviously poorly done. There were only whole apples and oranges - no cut up fruit and neither option was easy to eat with plastic silverware - at breakfast.
I know it all sounds picayune, but it just felt like a considerably lessened experience, and it was also considerably more expensive. We were very disappointed, and, though we travel to Allegany several times a year, we likely won't be back.